Rangnath report anti Hindu, anti national:Togadiya
Rangnath report anti Hindu, anti national:Togadiya
Ahmedabad, 18 December, 2009
Criticising Justice Rangnath Mishra Commission report recommending 10 per cent reservation for Muslims, Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) today said religion based reservation is unconstitutional.
The report of the National Commission for Religious and Linguistic Minorities headed by former CJI Ranganath Mishra was tabled by Minority Affairs Minister Salman Khurshid in the Lok Sabha today.
The Commission has recommended 10 per cent reservation for Muslims and five per cent for other minorities in government jobs.
“VHP rejects in toto the Rangnath commission report because it is unconstitutional, anti-national and anti-Hindu,” VHP international general secretary Praveen Togadia told media persons here.
“Khurshid who had recently called salaries of CEOs as vulgar, has by tabling the Rangnath Commission report shown the country his ‘constitutional vulgarity’,” he said.
“Implementation of such a report is set to encourage religious conversions, particularly among the Scheduled Castes, the Scheduled Tribes and other backward classes to take advantage of this development,” he said.
“The present government is trying to undo the conscious decision of the constituent assembly not to provide for religion-based reservation.”
“The implementation of the report will mean death for the Hindu SCs, STs and OBCs and their children,” he added.
Background
The central government’s decision to table the Ranganath Misra commission report in Parliament has invited agitation. Here is a small introduction of RN Mishra report and its background.
The UPA government set up the commission in 2005, during its first tenure. The four-member panel submitted its report on May 21,2007.
The Misra-led National Commission on Backward Religious and Linguistic Minorities has recommended 15 per cent reservation for minorities – 10 per cent for Muslims – in education and jobs. In case it’s difficult to achieve, the panel proposes breaking up of the 27 per cent quota for Other Backward Classes (OBC) to give minorities an 8.4 per cent share. Six per cent of it will be for Muslims. Pro-quota parties like the Rashtriya Janata Dal, Lok Janashakti Party and Janata Dal (United) have welcomed the move. The BJP is not in favour of it. The Congress had proposed something similar in its poll manifesto.
“Reservation to backward Muslims within 27 per cent OBC quota is under active consideration,” Minority Affairs Minister Salman Khurshid said. The panel also recommends Scheduled Caste (SC) status for Dalit Muslims and Dalit Christians along with deprived sections, if any, among Jains and Parsis.
Only Hindu Sikhs and Buddhist Dalits have the SC status, under the Presidential Order 1950 (Para 3). “No member professing a religion different from Hinduism (Sikh and Buddh) shall be deemed to be a member of SC,” it says.
Widening quota could breach the Supreme Court’s 50 per cent cap on reservations.To implement 15 per cent reservation, the government will have to pull off a Bill requiring approval of two-thirds of members in both the Houses. Extending the SC status to Dalit Muslims and Christians will require a Bill to be cleared by simple majority, a relatively easy task.
| << Previous Post |
Vulgar and pervert Khurshid fundamentalist should go.
Some brain washed religious zealots like Khurshid or Sonia assisted by our enemies are hell-bent on dividing society on religion and communal lines. How to take advantage of someone’s misery has been their ambition and their playing ground. First of all they haven’t even learned the basics of Bhaarateeya sabhyataa and sanskruti aptly known as Hindutva, as evident from their ranting of abuses on our Swaraj ethos.
Too bad their environment never gave them the prism of a peaceful outlook. As a result they haven’t even learned the ABCs of human living, which is ALL CITIZENS ARE EQUAL.
Instead of focusing on Government duties and containing the price rise (by being elected to the office), these crooked individuals want to create an illusion of minority/majority and fool the public into a mess of social engineering!!.
I support Dr.Togadia for standing up to this nonsense of reservation meant for fanning fundamentalism. In all of Dr.Togadia’s cancer clinics across Ahmedabad he treats patients without asking their religion. Why can’t goondaraj Kangress learn a lesson or two from him.
The goondaraj Kangress should ask themselves, how long would they like to live like a Italian dog that is brain washed to be wagging tail for rest of their lives?
Only a genuine secularism as revealed in Law of duties (Sanatan Dharma) or Mother Geetaa, can make people realize their potential and offers the necessary freedom for every soul to explore their path to ultimate happiness of love.
Jay Shree Raam!
Vande Mataram
Now pay wages of voting for congress. I dont think congress will take political risk of giving reservations to minority. If minority jumps on this issue,, it will be double jeopardy for congress.
I find all absurd things which are unthinkable by the most common logic happening blatantly in India today. Be it chopping the nation like a meatpiece by greedy hawks aka salivating looters in garb of politicians; converting tribals to other religions; or now offering reservation to minorities.
While we do pay some passive attention to these stuffs (thanks to news channels and new papers), there are many more that we choose to ignore. Some examples are the decay in the political leadership in the country, growing influence of naxalism and many more.
I sincerely feel that the problems is with the Hindu religion itself. Basically a tolerant, albeit easily domitable, society, that got spolit by a few people in upper casts, evolving into one of the most divided community that was invariably self destructive, now stands puzzled and clueless, staring at horizon that seems to bring many unpleasant surprises. Contraction in the available resources, be it land or power or jobs; a nation that seems to be on the verge of next division, repeating 1947, and probably this time not in two but many more parts.
This is crisis, to which we, the hindus (pls excuse me if that sounds nonsecular) are blind to, has potential to enslave us once again on a scale that is going to be worse than our slavery for centuries to muslim invaders and english colonizers. The tragedy is, this time, there are lesser chances of likes of shivajis and bhagat singhs as our young turks are much happier celebrating their independce in pubs or capitalizing their intellact in corporates while giving a damn to their religion, nation and politics.
So what a typical middle class hindu should do? Well, sit back, and watch TV news channels that show how muslims in gaziabad are being targeted, or how ‘My name is Khan’ is going to show the plight of a community, the good work christian missionaries are doing, and how Hindus are unleashing the wave of terror; and criminals in the grab of saffron uniform who seem to be patronizing them. Pity!
The solution is a new sort of revolution: a mass scale socio-political-financial education to the original inhabitants of this nation. The education that informs that present situation, how their future will be shaped by the happenings. And this should be without any political affiliation. But I know it is a wish, a wish that never gonna fulfilled.
Soon India is acquiring the thinking of Sinhalese against tamils they are in war since there independence till now.
this is too long for any goverment to recognise the requirment of muslim , community is not in position even to compete for their daily requirment , NEITHER SC NOR ST CAN BE COMPARED WITH MUSLIMS ,MUSLIMS HAD BEEN KEPT IN DARKNESS FOR YEAR . WE ARE NOT IN POSITION EITHER ECONOMICAL OR POLITICAL TO REPRESENT WELL ,WE NEED RESERVATION OR COMPLETE OPEN COMPITITION , ATTRITION RATE OF MUSLIM IS SUCH HIGH THAT ONY 5 OUT OF 100 WHO TOOK PRIMARY EDUCATION GOES FOR HIGHER EDUCATION HOW CAN A COMMUNITY WHICH HARDLEY BARE ITS DAILY REQUIRMENT CAN GO FOR EDUCATION WHICH HAD BEEN MADE MOST PROFITABLE BUSINESS MY OUR POLITICIANS ,SHAME ON CONGRESS AND SHAME ON UPA FOR NOT PUBLISHING ATR OF RAGNATH COMITEE