Prime facie sedition case against Hardik: High Court
October 27, 2015
Ahmedabad
Gujarat High Court today said there is prime facie case of sedition against Patel quota agitation leader Hardik Patel, while refusing to quash the FIR filed against him in Surat.
However, the court has ordered to drop section 153 (A) (creating enmity between two communities) of IPC from the FIR.
Justice J B Pardiwala said there is prime facie case of sedition against Hardik as he had advised a youth to kill policemen.
The court gave its verdict in the petition filed by the accused’s father Bharat Patel to quash the sedition FIR filed against him.
“Advising a person to resort to violence and disturb peace in society amounts to sedition,” the court said.
Refusing to quash the sedition plaint, the court said, “Probe is in progress and picture will be clear by the end of the probe.”
“It’s open for Patidars (Patels) to demand quota by peaceful means, but what’s not permissible is any act that may jeopardise public tranquillity,” the court said.
Ordering to drop IPC section 153 (A) from the FIR, the court said that Hardik’s statement does not promote enmity between two communities as it is against police.
A case of sedition was filed against Hardik for his alleged controversial remarks instigating his community youth to kill policemen instead of committing suicide.
The sedition case has been filed under section 124(A) of IPC at Amroli Police Station in Surat under which any accused, if convicted, can be sentenced to maximum of life imprisonment, while the minimum sentence is of three years.
The section reads, “whoever, by words, either spoken or written..brings hatred or contempt, or excites disaffection towards the government shall be punishable with imprisonment for life…or with minimum imprisonment up to three years.”
Other IPC sections included in the FIR against Hardik are 115 (abetment of offence), 153-A (promoting enmity between different groups, 505-2 (incite one community against another) and 506 (criminal intimidation). .
The 22-year-old Patel leader had on October 3 allegedly advised a Surat-based youth from his community to kill cops rather than ending his life.
“If you have so much courage…then go and kill a couple of policemen. Patels never commit suicide,” Hardik had allegedly told the youth Vipul Desai, who had announced that he would commit suicide in support of the agitation.
Hardik had visited Desai’s house accompanied by a team of a news channel, which had aired the conversation later.
The first sedition complaint against Hardik was filed after almost 15 days of his controversial remarks. The second sedition case against him was filed in Ahmedabad and he is in custody of city Crime Branch in the case.
The quota stir leader has been hogging the limelight since the August 25 “mega-rally” of Patels in Ahmedabad and the subsequent violence across Gujarat in which 10 people were killed.
PTI
Related Stories
Sibal argues for half an hour for Hardik, SC sends plea to another bench
Gujarat HC refuses to quash sedition charge against Hardik
Sedition FIR against Hardik to crush the agitation: Gujarat Congress
Hardik Patel: From Rajkot to Ahmedabad via Surat, and Mahesana, Aravalli next
Hardik sought to block roads if arrested before India-SA ODI
Hardik's intention was to wage war against govt, spoke about throwing bomb in assembly:FIR
Explain why sedition charge against Hardik:HC to govt
Sedition case: Hardik remanded in police custody till Oct 23
Hardik on remand till 4.00 pm on 23 October
Hardik's father moves Gujarat HC to set aside sedition charges
Hardik's arrest, but no internet ban, RAF deployment this time
Released on bail in Rajkot, Hardik Patel arrested on sedition charge by Surat police
Surat Police to arrest Hardik Patel for sedition and other charges
HC junks Hardik's plea to recall 'sedition charge' inquiry
Probe Hardik Patel's speech, file sedition case if necessary: High Court
Recent Stories
- New Rules for RMC General Board Meetings in Rajkot get approval from Gujarat Govt
- Dr. Prashant Vazirani nabbed in connection with patient deaths at Khyati Hospital
- 58 lakh people impacted with our CSR initiatives in Gujarat: HDFC Bank
- Reliance, Disney announce completion of transaction to form joint venture; Nita Ambani to be chairperson
- DGP Vikas Sahay calls father of MICA student killed by cop in Bopal road rage incident
- Severed calf head found in Umargam; locals demand action
- Trailer truck driver held in Rajasthan for death of Gujarat PSI